DEMANDS have been made in Parliament to close “a plain gap” in the law following the revenge killing of a former prison officer.
The call for the tightening up of legislation comes after career criminal Elias Morgan gunned down dad-of-three Lenny Scott, from Prescot, for seizing a phone from his cell years earlier.
Because Mr Scott had left the prison service by then, Morgan did not face the harshest penalty available of a whole life order, meaning he would never be released from jail.
He was instead sentenced to serve a minimum of 45 years behind bars.
Currently, those who kill an on-duty prison or police officer can expect the most severe prison sentence, where they spend the rest of their life in jail.
The Conservatives argue this should be expanded to include offenders who murder off-duty or former officers because of their job.
Pressing for a change to the Sentencing Bill currently going through Parliament, Tory frontbencher Lord Sandhurst said: “We have seen the consequences of the existing drafting. The tragic case of former prison officer Lenny Scott revealed the gap starkly.”
The 33-year-old found a phone in Morgan’s cell while working at HMP Altcourse in Merseyside.
When he refused a bribe to turn a blind eye and duly reported the find, which revealed Morgan was in a sexual relationship with a female prison officer, the convict threatened his family and vowed revenge.
Almost four years later, after Morgan had served his sentence and Mr Scott had left the Prison Service, he carried out the threat.
Mr Scott was leaving a gym in Skelmersdale on February 8, 2024, when he was shot six times by Morgan.
Elias Morgan was sentenced to a minimum term of 45 years (Image: Lancashire Police)
Lord Sandhurst said: “It was a murder directly and unequivocally connected to the past performance of his duties.
“This was a gangland execution intended to punish Lenny for doing his duty and not giving way to what had been asked of him, and to terrify and intimidate other prison officers into doing gangsters’ bidding in the future.
“Because this crime did not occur in the course of his duty but a couple of years later, the statutory framework failed to treat it as the kind of murder for which Parliament provides the highest penalty and the judge therefore did not pass a whole-life order.
“This is a clear loophole in the legislation, and I look to the minister to put it right. How many more Lennies will there be?”
He added: “How many serving or former officers walk our streets knowing that they will remain potential targets long after they take off the uniform, and knowing that under the law as presently interpreted, their killers may not face the penalty that Parliament intended for those who attack innocent public servants?”
Lenny Scott (Image: Lancashire Police)
Lord Sandhurst went on: “We cannot undo the tragedy that happened to Lenny Scott and his family, nor repair the pain, but we can ensure that the law is changed.
“We can ensure that the sentencing framework recognises that the risks to officers do not end when their shift finishes and certainly do not disappear when they have left the force.
“When a murder is motivated and driven by the officer’s service, the seriousness, risk and moral culpability are exactly the same.
“This is a plain gap in the legislation as currently drafted, and it must be closed immediately.”
Responding, justice minister Lord Timpson said a whole-life order was “normally the appropriate starting point” for the murder of a police or prison officer when they are on duty.
Read more
- Drug driver banned from road as he appears in dock
- Police name six charged after break-in at business park
- Man caught with 10 wraps of cocaine sentenced by court
- Man arrested after copper wire stripped from business premises in burglary
- Emergency crews rush to scene after casualty falls down embankment
He told peers: “This provision was introduced to recognise the unique and dangerous job that police and prison officers do on a daily basis.”
The minister added: “Like so many of our dedicated and hard-working prison officers, Lenny devoted his career to working with some of this country’s most dangerous and challenging offenders.
“In Lenny’s case, the judge considered that this starting point did not apply as he was not a serving prison officer at the time of the murder.
“However, the judge did impose a life sentence, with a 45-year minimum term to be served in custody, so it is likely that the perpetrator in this case will spend the rest of his life in prison, given that he was 35 at the time of conviction.”
Lord Timpson pointed out that the Law Commission, at the request of the Government, was currently undertaking a wholesale review of the sentencing framework for murder.
He said: “Any changes to the framework, including to whole-life orders, should be considered in the context of this review. It would not be appropriate to make changes before that has finished.”
Share