News RSS Feed


Carole raises alarm over trapped swans


A FAMILY of swans have been left trapped in filth and rubbish and at the mercy of yobs as a row breaks out over the upkeep of Carr Mill Dam.

Moss Bank Councillor Carole Kavanagh says she is growing increasingly frustrated over the lack of action to prevent birds being frequently swept over the overflow at the dam.

She is also pushing British Waterways, who are responsible for the upkeep of the water to play their part.

In the latest incident, Cllr Kavanagh claims that she was told by an RSPCA inspector that they wouldn’t rescue the birds, as they would be washed over again.

She blasted: “On TV you are shown the fabulous rescues the RSPCA perform, so it unbelievable that they won’t do this.” Several members of the public raised concerns over the fate of the birds after cygnets were killed at the same spot last year by stone throwing louts.

Cllr Kavanagh also expressed her frustration over the perceived lack of action from British Waterways, who have so far failed to answer her calls to erect a small barrier at the crest of the overflow.

They say that if a “trash screen” were to be installed in front of the overspill, it must be maintained on a regular basis, to clear any vegetation and floating debris. If left unchecked, they claim, it could lead to extensive flooding.

They offered an alternative suggestion of a “duck ramp”, to stop birds being washed over, adding that they would consider any modifications as long as the costs were met by the council, including the daily maintenance.

A spokesperson from the RSPCA confirmed that they had received several calls about the swan and cygnets over a 17 day period.

The birds were found by an Animal Collection Officer (ACO) who said that in her judgement, they were not in any danger as they were feeding well and there were plenty of platforms for them to leave the water.

The spokesperson confirmed: “The RSPCA received several calls about a family of swans washed over an overflow on Carr Mill Dam. An Animal Collection Officer attended and there have been numerous visits since.

“The swans are not suffering. They are feeding well and are able to get out of the water, but the RSPCA is continuing to monitor the situation and is checking on the birds regularly to make sure they are ok.

“Under the Wildlife and Countryside Act it is illegal to move a wild bird unless it is injured or suffering.”


Your Say Your Star

BillMitch, Earlestown says...
11:40am Sat 11 Jul 09

you usually get these stories from councillors when an election is imminent but i don't think there are any this year.

PM, Newton says...
3:25pm Sat 11 Jul 09

according to the council website there's an upcoming by election in Moss bank which is where cllr kavanagh is a councillor.although i'm sure this is totally unrelated to the great swan rescue

godofhellfire, St Helens says...
2:39pm Sun 12 Jul 09

the adult swan & 2 cygnets are still there this morning. We went down to the edge of the water & all 3 came to us as if they wanted help. 7 ducklings were at the top of the overflow with nowhere to go.

PM, Newton says...
4:24pm Sun 12 Jul 09

So if they aren't dead and can escape-I'm sure the RSCPCA are the experts, what's the problem? Why is it suddenly an issue now when there have been swans and ducks at Carr Mill Dam since the year dot?

sthlsa, st helens says...
5:25pm Sun 12 Jul 09

i live in moss bank and can safely say that unlike their rivals, the liberal democrats here do not only come out of the woodwork at election time. the last time we heard from the labour candidate jeff fletcher? a year ago when he lost to carole kavanagh, and then coincidentally i had a labour rose with his mug on delivered through my door as news of the by election spread, where as i have had several LD leaflets. the swans have always been a concern and as an animal lover carole is showing as much concern over the swans as she does with pets corner and any other defenceless animals.

PM, Newton says...
6:23pm Sun 12 Jul 09

Should we put her up for a sainthood? She sounds wonderful and i'm sure her concern for swans stretch way beyond elections, she should start her own lib dem RSPCA.The difference between the lib dems and labour is like the difference between toothache and a headache.

BillMitch, Earlestown says...
7:01pm Sun 12 Jul 09

So there IS an election!! I should have my own TV show. My sympathies to the people of Moss Bank who are probably sick to the back teeth of it already.

Scotty99, Dentons Green says...
4:28am Mon 13 Jul 09

local election between 70% and 80% of the public don't even bother to vote.That tells you all you need to know what people think about councillors.As for the swans the rspca are the experts, the council should stick to the job they are paid to do and do it properly before lecturing others on their responsibilties.

Comments are closed on this article.


Want to share your opinion, leave a tribute or comment on a news story? It's easy!
You can register for free here and comment on any of our stories. Your news, Your views.

Local advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »